Anyone who wants to turn meetings, interviews or lectures into text has two routes today. One is an app on the phone or computer that records and transcribes. The other is a separate recording device that captures the audio and hands it to an AI service for transcripts and summaries. Both routes lead to a written record, yet they behave differently in everyday use. This article walks through those differences without ranking them. As a device example it uses the Plaud Note Pro, and as app examples it mentions Otter.ai and Fireflies.ai. All device details in this article are manufacturer specifications.
Two routes to the same goal
An app uses hardware that is already there: the microphone of the phone, laptop or headset, together with its storage and battery. Many apps can also connect to video calls and take part in an online meeting as a participant. A dedicated recorder is an extra object to carry. It has its own microphones, its own battery and its own storage, and it records independently of the phone. The phone or a web app is then used to transfer the recording and to read the transcript. Which route fits depends on where conversations take place: mostly on screen, mostly in a room, or a mix of both.
The device side: Plaud Note Pro
According to the manufacturer, the Plaud Note Pro weighs 30 g and has roughly the format of a credit card, with a thickness of 2.99 mm. It has 4 microphones with a stated pickup range of up to 5 metres. The battery is specified for 30 hours of recording and up to 50 hours in power saving mode, and the internal storage holds 64 GB. The device connects via Bluetooth Low Energy 5.4 and Wi-Fi. The manufacturer lists the price at €189 and states that transcription is available in more than 112 languages. Further recording devices are collected in our product overview.
Transcription minutes and plans
With both routes the transcription usually runs as a cloud service, and that service has its own pricing. For the Plaud Note Pro the manufacturer states 300 minutes of transcription per month without a subscription. More minutes are offered in paid plans: the manufacturer lists a Pro plan at €19.99 per month and an Unlimited plan at €34.99 per month. The device price and the plan are therefore two separate items. Apps such as Otter and Fireflies also work with free and paid plans. Their current conditions are described on the respective tool pages in our directory.
Differences in everyday use
A separate device keeps the phone free during a recording, so calls or other apps do not compete with the recording for the microphone or the battery. At the same time it is one more device to charge, carry and pair. Apps need no extra hardware and are often already installed on the computer that is used for online meetings. In both cases the audio is processed by an external service for transcription, so it makes sense to check where the data is stored and who can access it. These points describe trade offs that carry different weight depending on the situation, and they do not form a ranking.
Legal note: record only with consent
In Germany, recording the non-public spoken word of another person without consent is a criminal offence under Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB). This applies regardless of whether the recording is made with an app or with a dedicated device. Before recording, inform everyone taking part in the conversation and ask for their consent. Other countries have their own rules. This note is general information and does not replace legal advice.
FAQ
Does an AI voice recorder replace a transcription app?
Not automatically. A recorder like the Plaud Note Pro also relies on an app and a cloud service for the transcript; the device itself handles the recording. Whether one replaces the other depends on whether conversations happen mostly in rooms or mostly in online calls.
How many transcription minutes come with the Plaud Note Pro?
According to the manufacturer, 300 minutes per month without a subscription. More minutes are available in the paid Pro and Unlimited plans. Current details are on the product page.
Can I record a conversation without telling the other people?
In Germany, recording the non-public spoken word without consent is punishable under Section 201 StGB. Ask everyone involved for consent before recording, whether with an app or with a device.
Photo: Julia Filirovska / Pexels
